Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
A classic cheese pizza on an aluminum tray at a dark walnut pizzeria booth, with soft late-autumn light through the window.

Where to Get Pizza in Old Bridge, Road by Road

Old Bridge has no downtown pizza block, so the town's pizza map follows its roads. County Road 516 has three shops with three different kinds of pie. Route 9 has the shop that has been making dough there since 1978. Route 34 has the pie that put Old Bridge highest on NJ.com's ranking of New Jersey's 125 best pizzas for 2026, and you can only order it on Saturdays and Sundays.

If you already know which road you live closest to, you can figure out your usual order from there. If you're hosting family over Thanksgiving weekend, the three roads give you three very different pies to choose from.

County Road 516 Has Three Shops and Three Ovens

On the 516 corridor, two pizzerias have street numbers only nine apart. G'Zepps Old School Italian Pizzeria is at 2581 County Road 516, and Krispy Pizza's Old Bridge shop is at 2590. They are close neighbors, but they make different pizza.

Krispy's family history starts in Brooklyn. In a 2018 feature, MyCentralJersey reported that the business was started in Brooklyn about 50 years earlier by Peter Pallazzola and that his sons Vinny, Tony, Freddy and Al carried it on. The same article lists the pies Krispy is known for: a thin-crust Grandma's Sicilian, a fresh mozzarella pie, a vodka sauce pie and a chicken Parmesan pie. Krispy's Palermo pie took second place in that paper's 2018 top-10 tomato pie poll.

Eight years later, the vodka pie has a newer endorsement. NJ.com's 2026 ranking, published September 22, put Krispy's vodka pie at No. 112 out of 125 and listed the chain's locations as Freehold, Old Bridge, Jersey City and New Brunswick. If you also shop in Freehold, the chain's Freehold location is another place to get that vodka pie, and we've covered that town's Freehold Marketplace food stops separately.

G'Zepps, across the road, describes its pizza on its own site as classic New York style. It also keeps the longest hours of the three 516 shops. Its online ordering page lists pickup from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday through Saturday and from noon to 10 p.m. on Sunday. It's open seven days a week, so G'Zepps is the 516 option on Monday and Tuesday nights, when the coal-fired place up the road is closed.

That coal-fired place is Via Sposito, farther along at 3857 County Road 516. Its Old Bridge page describes a family-friendly BYOB kitchen that makes coal-fired pizza, pasta from scratch and its own mozzarella, and lists hours Wednesday through Sunday. Brothers Anthony and Vincent Esposito Jr. are the fourth generation of the family behind it.

Via Sposito is also the one Old Bridge pizzeria on this list that Dave Portnoy has reviewed. Patch covered the visit in August 2024. MyCentralJersey's May 2025 roundup of Portnoy's central New Jersey reviews reported that co-owner Anthony Esposito wanted him to try the Margherita with homemade mozzarella, and that Portnoy gave the thin coal-fired pie a 7.4 out of 10.

So one stretch of 516 has a Brooklyn family's Sicilian and vodka pies, a New York-style shop open every day, and a BYOB coal oven. You can get Grandma pie, a classic slice or a charred Margherita without leaving the corridor. For the non-pizza side of the corridor, see our look at two Old Bridge restaurants on Route 516.

Route 9 Has the Shop That Opened in 1978

Old Bridge Restaurant & Pizzeria is at 3165 U.S. Highway 9. Its website says it has been established since 1978 and makes its dough fresh every day. That makes 48 years on the Route 9 side of town as of 2026.

The site also takes orders online, so it's an easy weeknight call if you live off Route 9.

The town's two ranked pies, Via Sposito's coal-fired Margherita and the Route 34 nihari, got their recognition from Portnoy and NJ.com. This shop's case rests on having stayed in business on the same highway since the late 1970s.

Route 34 Has the Weekend-Only Nihari Pie

Jaan's Pizza, at 42 NJ-34, holds Old Bridge's highest spot on NJ.com's 2026 list, at No. 37. NJ.com's reviewer, Vashti Harris, describes Jaan's as a halal pizzeria that makes traditional Italian pizza alongside slices and pies with toppings inspired by Pakistani and Indian dishes.

The ranked pie is the nihari pizza. It's topped with slow-cooked, slightly spicy beef, mozzarella, garlic, finely chopped green chilies, ginger and fresh cilantro. In NJ.com's ranking, Harris wrote that a squeeze of lemon brought out the spices. The pie comes with a cup of the spiced broth the nihari was cooked in, which she said made dipping it feel like an Indian birria pizza.

The detail that matters most for planning is in the same entry: the nihari pie is only sold on Saturdays and Sundays. Old Bridge's best-ranked pie on the 2026 list is a weekend-only order.

Jaan's own ordering site posted its schedule for the week of November 15. That week, Monday was listed as closed, Sunday pickup started at noon, and pickup ran to 9 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday and to 9:30 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. Delivery ran until 10 p.m. on those two nights. Holiday weeks can run differently, so check the site before you plan around a specific hour.

Thanksgiving Weekend, Planned by Road and Day

The posted hours make the long weekend fairly easy to plan.

The nihari pie is available Saturday, November 28, and Sunday, November 29, the weekend after Thanksgiving, since Jaan's sells it only on Saturdays and Sundays. If relatives are staying through Sunday, that's the window for the Route 34 pie.

Via Sposito lists Wednesday through Sunday hours in Old Bridge, so its coal-fired pies fit the same weekend. The BYOB setup suits a sit-down dinner for a table of visitors. The Via Sposito events page also lists a $395 Thanksgiving catering package for 8 to 10 people, with cold pickup on Wednesday, November 25, at all three of its locations. Thanksgiving Day dine-in is listed only at the Colts Neck location.

G'Zepps lists hours every day of the week, and Old Bridge Restaurant & Pizzeria takes orders online. Those are the two to keep in mind for the Monday after the holiday, since Jaan's posted November schedule had Monday closed and Via Sposito's Old Bridge hours run Wednesday through Sunday.

If you only order from one of these roads, the other two are a short drive away.

Which pizzeria is closest can be a small factor in choosing a street, especially for families who order on Friday nights. If you're weighing a move within Old Bridge, or from here to another part of Monmouth or Middlesex County, The Tully Group can show you how homes near each of these corridors are pricing right now. Start with a free home valuation and market plan, or browse our Old Bridge neighborhood page to see what's for sale near your road.